- Thread starter
- #21
freemotion
Food Guru
Here is the common confusion, and the way I was mis-taught:TanksHill said:Ok I need someone to clear up the nonhydrogenated thing for me. From what I have read its just basically poison for us. So what is the definition of hydrogenated vs not? Whats the difference? Someone mentioned Spanish foods often have the non-hydrogenated kind. I have tons of ethnic stores around here. And what about the coconut oils. My auntie really was recommending those.
Ok I just checked the Living foods coconut oil is NON hydrogenated. Maybe that's why she recommended it.
sorry this is so off topic.
I was taught that anything that is solid at room temp is bad and anything liquid at room temp is good. This is incorrect.
Hydrogenated (trans fats) are fats that have been processed to make them harder. It was a method invented so that soap could be made with lower quality oils and get nice and hard. Someone discovered that it would make a Twinkie last for a hundred years and still stay soft (note the sarcasm....) And it is CHEAP to manufacture, because they can use basically garbage and make it pretty and white and essentially flavorless, as Americans have come to expect. So the campain against lard and beef fat began.
Remember the hype about McD's switching from beef fat to veg shortening for their fryers? It did us no favors.
Now with the campain against trans and hydrogenated fats, McD's and others are switching to cheap veg oils. Hexane and other solvents are used to get every molecule of oil out of the soy, canola, etc. And then it is all cleaned and bleached to be colorless and odorless. Not healthy, in spite of the word "vegetable" in its name.
Coconut oil is very healthy. Solid or liquid at room...or body....temp has nothing to do with it.
The very best fats are from well-raised animals and home-rendered when possible, no bleaching or chemicals needed because we are careful of how we handle our own food. For vegetable oil, expeller-pressed or cold-pressed on the label means no solvents, which will be stated proudly.
For lots of details on this and the science part, Mary Enid and Sally Fallon wrote "Eat Fat, Lose Fat" which is a very interesting book. They go a bit overboard with the coconut oil, IMHO, but it is eye-opening. I am a big fan of variety in ones' diet and also everyone is genetically different, how our ancestors adapted to what was available will influence what is the best for us. Difficult to determine, but it just means experiment and know that what makes me healthy may not make you healthy in every detail.
However, hydrogenated and trans fats are very bad for everyone. You might as well use motor oil in your salad dressing! But more insidious, presented as healthy foods. It is criminal how we have been betrayed.