I built night stands from red oak and pine. Well, at least the tops anyway. The tops are butcher block style with 7/16 strips glued, planed, and molded edges. I alternated the oak and pine for color contrast. They are only 2 or so years old now so I cant really speak to their durability yet. However, I think the pine looks great laid in next to the red oak and my guess is that it will for a long time. I finished the table with clear pour filler and 8 coats of polyurethane. which I believe should compensate for the relative softness of the pine. -- just my 2 cents.