Is self sufficiency sustainability?

Buster

Lovin' The Homestead
Joined
Jan 28, 2009
Messages
408
Reaction score
0
Points
84
Location
Rural Oklahoma
Beekissed said:
Buster, going on my Lunatic Tour at Joel's place on May 11th!!!
:weee :celebrate :ya :D

Can't wait!!! :love
:barnie Okay, now I'm jealous!!

:D

Have fun. Tell him his old buddy Buster says hey!

Even though we've never met. :gig
 

Buster

Lovin' The Homestead
Joined
Jan 28, 2009
Messages
408
Reaction score
0
Points
84
Location
Rural Oklahoma
freemotion said:
Sorry, Buster. Not completely typical. What were we talking about? ;)
That's okay. Semantic games aside, it has been very helpful. It has proved my suspicion that by and large people who do this self sufficiency thing get it, and those who don't, don't.

The distraction actually helped prove that point.
 

ohiofarmgirl

Sipping Bacon Martinis
Joined
Aug 18, 2009
Messages
5,488
Reaction score
0
Points
189

Quail_Antwerp

Cold is on the Right, Hot is on The Left
Joined
Sep 12, 2008
Messages
6,905
Reaction score
6
Points
262
Location
Ohio
Mine and Becca's meaties arrive next week, I think. :p
 

cmjust0

Power Conserver
Joined
Feb 19, 2010
Messages
57
Reaction score
0
Points
28
Alright, so...here's what I'm taking from this thread.

1) To be "self-sufficient," on this forum, doesn't really have that much to do with actual self sufficiency, where one would have the ability to live without outside aid or input of any kind. It simply means trying or actually being able to do some stuff for yourself, but not necessarily all stuff. The amount of stuff you can do for yourself isn't really as important as the effort when it comes to being considered an SS'er.

2) Having to purchase some things from some people can be more "self-sufficient-y" than buying some other things from some other people, regardless of the fact that they're both input from an outside source.. For instance, having to buy nails from your neighbor who's a blacksmith is considered more self-sufficient-y than having to buy nails from Lowe's.

3) Even though having to purchase things and requiring input from outside sources is totally OK under many circumstances, having a job that pays for everything you need doesn't make you self sufficient. You have to do some stuff for yourself. Working at the aforementioned job and making enough money to pay other people to do things you need done doesn't really count.

4) Nobody on this forum believes that actual self-sufficiency...in the strictest sense of the phrase where a person wouldn't need any outside aid or input...is attainable -- or even desirable, apparently -- and as such, nobody actually strives toward that goal.


None of that really makes any sense to me, personally, but if that more or less sums it up, then I really haven't a leg to stand on. If that's the case, I'll hush.

So...is that about right?
 

Buster

Lovin' The Homestead
Joined
Jan 28, 2009
Messages
408
Reaction score
0
Points
84
Location
Rural Oklahoma
I would add

5. Cmjust0 has no clue about Self Sufficient living or the purpose of this site, but apparently visits it and participates in it anyway strictly for the sake of amusement. :lol:

ETA
I would quibble with some of your conclusions but sense it is just bait to draw folks into another tributary of off-topic (for this thread) meanderings, so I think I'm going to pass and just say you are welcome to draw your own conclusions and to your own opinion, as we all are.

I certainly have mine. :)
 

big brown horse

Hoof In Mouth
Joined
Apr 23, 2009
Messages
8,307
Reaction score
0
Points
213
Location
Puget Sound, WA
Buster said:
I would add

5. Cmjust0 has no clue about Self Sufficient living or the purpose of this site, but apparently visits it and participates in it anyway strictly for the sake of amusement. :lol:
AHHHH MEN!!!
ETA
I would quibble with some of your conclusions but sense it is just bait to draw folks into another tributary of off-topic (for this thread) meanderings, so I think I'm going to pass and just say you are welcome to draw your own conclusions and to your own opinion, as we all are.



I certainly have mine. :)
Why bother????

:rant I don't care what cmj-whoever has to say about how self sufficient we are or aren't, for goodness sakes IT ISN'T A RACE!! We are doing what we can with what we have to make this a better planet, to grow healthier food for ourselves, to save a load of money, to cut back our electricity costs, raise healthy meat FREE FROM ANTIBIOTICS :tongue and gmo corn etc. We are all in it for some of the same or different reasons, but we are in it to make a difference.

The fact of the matter is that we are doing something, some of us on a small scale some of us on a large one like Miss. Puff, who chooses to NOT have electricity or running water etc.

Can we just ignore him/her (?) and carry on a discussion??????
 

noobiechickenlady

Almost Self-Reliant
Joined
May 12, 2009
Messages
3,046
Reaction score
1
Points
154
Location
North Central Miss'ippy
Farmfresh said:
How about a civilization where we use technology and the Earth in unison. You know wind power, solar power, geothermal power, hydro power. Heck lets even harness the tides. Use all of that power for good - not Monsanto. Melt that sand in big old factories and make my glass jars and my metal stove, but this time make my metal stove one that will REALLY truly last. Make the parts simple. Make them easy to repair. Make it so useful and reliable I will not only, NEVER want to buy another one - my grand kids won't be needing a new one either.
AMEN!!!!! Farmfresh, that whole post was great. :clap

While I would love to live as a hermit in the woods with my DH, kids, goats, rabbits, chickens & the wildlife for company, it would still be great to occasionally travel down the gravel road to see the sights, pick up some nails, sugar & coffee & have a nice cold beer that I didn't brew myself, while listening to the old biddies at the coffee shop gossip.

Get 'em BBH!!
 
Top