Mackay
Almost Self-Reliant
- Joined
- Oct 7, 2008
- Messages
- 1,332
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 128
Actually, I am qualified to give medical advice. Anyone can give medical advice. What you can not do is diagnose, prescribe and treat in most states. But in my state I can.Icu4dzs said:Dear Friends,
This particular string distresses me greatly. We are not here to practice medicine, although apparently a few of us feel qualified to give medical advice to an ailing member.
He already has a diagnosis. I told him what other people are doing to treat this very dangerous disease, and if he continues on the path he may be risking his wellbeing for a very long time.
Amoxicillin is a third generation in the penicillin class of antibiotics. It is not penicillin. They made a third generation for a good reason, that being that penicillin does not work on many things. If you want you will find 30 or more links from all kinds of medical sites that do not mention penicillin for lyme disease. It is not a drug of choice.Icu4dzs said:Of significance is the fact that one member states that penicillin is NOT indicated for Lyme disease and provides a link to prove his point. Unfortunately, this link not only fails to prove his point, it clearly mentions Amoxicillin which is a "third generation" aminopenicillin as a remedy for Lyme disease. Getting medical advice on the internet can be done but it probably ought to come from someone qualified to give it or an institution which has a respectable reputation in that field.
Actually he already has a diagnosis. He is treating himself in conjuntion with a doctor. What he choses to do for his own health he will chose for himself. He is capable of doing his own research. He came her asking for advice. I did not solicite him. He's a big guy who just didn't have enough information on the disease he has. Now he has it. He will make his own decisions.Icu4dzs said:Bottom line here is that we are not here to diagnose and treat the diseases of others. It is particularly unwise to accept such a recommendation as well.
Yes, this doctor was trained yet the treatment is not right. This doctor is failing and the training he received has failed too.Icu4dzs said:While many in medical profession may be lacking in some of their particularly important diagnostic skills, they have at least completed the required training to be qualified to recommend a particular treatment, assuming the diagnosis is correct.
I think you need to understand what the meaning of the word diagnose. He already has a diagnosis, and by the way he describes his disease, its likely 98% accurate. I have told him that he should consult with another doctor who is Lyme Literate and I gave him contact information. He is likely to find that some of these doctors are using mms or similar medicines by IV or samento as well as very specific antibiotics, not including penicillin.Icu4dzs said:Since several here question the ability of the diagnostic skills of the members of the medical profession and recommend the Naturopathic physicians, it would be also wise to investigate more thoroughly the "remedies" that are being touted on this forum as well as the "success rate of those healers. I for one question the diagnostic approach of those who would recommend treatments for members here without a complete understanding of the problem and a few sentences of complaint certainly do NOT constitute adequate investigation of the problem.
Actually chlorite is not spelled wrong and it is not chloride. Sodium chlorite has absolutely nothing to do with table salt. You are way down on the learning curve to be making such comments. Many people get good results using MMS for lyme disease, most specifically chronic lyme disease.Icu4dzs said:For instance, what EXACTLY is MMS? Does anyone know for sure? One person stated it was exactly LIKE sodium chlorite (correct spelling is chloride) which in reality is table salt and water. I don't imagine anyone is completely convinced that plain table salt will cure the diseases mentioned here.
I gave him all references needed to find out what mms is.Icu4dzs said:Additionally, since the folks who are "selling" these cures on the internet do not tell you exactly what is in their "remedy" then it should raise the red flags mentioned above by the member who feels that penicillin is not indicated for Lyme Disease. If you don't know what you are putting into your body, perhaps you should reconsider it and find out exactly what is in it first.
Antibiotics do not have a proven 100 percent efficacy in treating lyme disease, ESPECIALLY if they are given the wrong antibiotic from the start. Why would anyone continue with a drug that will not work after they became aware that it probably won't work. People have adverse effects and even die from the use of antibiotics everyday.Icu4dzs said:For that matter, why would you take a "remedy" that has not been scientifically tested to show proof of its efficacy in treating that specific disease or proble?. Just because your friend said "it worked for me' does NOT mean it will work for you. If you are unfortunate enough to be allergic to a "remedy" more's the pity when you are adversely affected by it.
Physicans do harm all the time and further more they do not take such oaths. It is a myth that doctors currently take the Hyppocratic Oath.Icu4dzs said:While medicine is an art, it is conducted with the benefit of the scientific approach and in all but a very few cases, with the ethics instilled in each and every physician who takes the oath of a physician by promising to "first, do no harm".
If you think placebo effect will take care of Lyme disease you might do better to stop the philosophies and wake up.Icu4dzs said:There are in some cases, complete resolution of illnesses based on the miracle of the human body being able to heal itself. Then there is the placebo where the person thinks they are relieved because their mind wills it to be so.
I gave this man links to finding true help from licensed physicians. Just because you had a friend who culd not make correct choices for her own health does not mean that others are incapable. Anyone who is looking at options on the internet should do research on those options and find out if they are viable options for themselves.Icu4dzs said:Therefore in summary, we are all here to help each other, but in some things, seeking the advice of those unqualified to give it can result in disastrous consequences and then you have no one to blame but yourself.