Thanks FF
My apology to Jamie was for
my hijack away from his question, especially as this is his thread and I completely missed it in my initial glance-through.
My opinions about the book, however, stand. Balance is truly what is important.
I know so many people who have incredibly varied and very specific dietary needs. It's interesting that there is a thread going at the moment about how dieticians don't have people's best interests at heart, because I know a couple and they offer a much more balanced approach than what I
assume the OP in that thread believes they do. People are as individual as snowflakes, there is no one
right way to eat for optimum health. There are guidelines that may work for
most people, but not all.
The book in question is about
traditional foods and traditional food preparation, and misses the mark in many instances. Ph.D. is great, I know it means Doctor, however it confers a level of educational study and doesn't mean medical doctor. Opinions presented as fact are very dangerous. Everyone who writes a book has a bias, and the bias in this particular book hits the reader over the head. It is always prudent to investigate sources, determine who has something to sell (such as the fact that the writer of one particular source cited in the book owns the largest chain of organic bakeries in North America) or an axe to grind, and proceed cautiously.
I am extremely fortunate that I am the product of traditional cooking and enjoy excellent health, as do the rest of my family. We work to ensure that we do the best we can to take care of ourselves. My belief has always been all things in moderation, and moderation in all things. The occasional sweet treat won't hurt anyone (unless it contains allergens or ingredients to which the consumer has sensitivity).
It's funny to me that there is this perceived resurgence of interest in self sufficiency and holistic health, because it has always been a part of my life. I don't do much different in my everyday life than my parents or grandparents did, except that I have some newer technology in my life (computers etc.) than they had access to. The comments about lean cuisine and hamburger helper just go right over my head, because I've never even glanced at products like those, let alone eaten them.