frustratedearthmother
Sustainability Master
I agree with @Mini Horses - an open pasture vs. a wooded area will make aerial predation much more prevalent. It doesn't really have anything to do with someone saying "my birds don't get eaten and you're a bad person because yours do."
Having a place to hide vs. having to run for your life makes a big difference. My birds are cage and coop free. But, I have perimeter fences and smaller fenced areas also. Some stay in the front barnyard, some are in pastures with the goats/pigs/horses and dogs. None of them are behind closed doors at night. Most do choose to go under a roof at night and they have several open shelters to choose from. But, I do have a few that choose to roost on a fence post - totally in the open. They are still there in the morning.
Basically, the chickens can go where they want - including outside the perimeter occasionally. I rarely lose one, but it has happened. I've seen one eagle here in my entire life so that's not a big problem. We have bobcats that won't test the dogs nor will coyotes. But, dogs prefer to stay with the goats so sometimes the chickens are on their own. I have, on two occasions, found a chicken body with no head. No marks on the rest of the body. Owl maybe? Coon? I don't know but that's only happened twice in probably ten years. My own dog is the worst predator I have. Not the LGD's but the varmint dog. She can't stand something small that runs fast - so she gets 'em. Sometimes what she gets are small young birds. Happens when they come into "her" yard. She doesn't share her space!
I have used chicken tractors successfully when raising young ones. I don't over crowd them and I do move them frequently. They do well under those circumstances. I have seen many insects that are attracted to poo - not ones that run from it. Birds eat those insects along with the taller grasses in the tractor area. Move them, rinse, repeat. Works for me.
Having a place to hide vs. having to run for your life makes a big difference. My birds are cage and coop free. But, I have perimeter fences and smaller fenced areas also. Some stay in the front barnyard, some are in pastures with the goats/pigs/horses and dogs. None of them are behind closed doors at night. Most do choose to go under a roof at night and they have several open shelters to choose from. But, I do have a few that choose to roost on a fence post - totally in the open. They are still there in the morning.
Basically, the chickens can go where they want - including outside the perimeter occasionally. I rarely lose one, but it has happened. I've seen one eagle here in my entire life so that's not a big problem. We have bobcats that won't test the dogs nor will coyotes. But, dogs prefer to stay with the goats so sometimes the chickens are on their own. I have, on two occasions, found a chicken body with no head. No marks on the rest of the body. Owl maybe? Coon? I don't know but that's only happened twice in probably ten years. My own dog is the worst predator I have. Not the LGD's but the varmint dog. She can't stand something small that runs fast - so she gets 'em. Sometimes what she gets are small young birds. Happens when they come into "her" yard. She doesn't share her space!
I have used chicken tractors successfully when raising young ones. I don't over crowd them and I do move them frequently. They do well under those circumstances. I have seen many insects that are attracted to poo - not ones that run from it. Birds eat those insects along with the taller grasses in the tractor area. Move them, rinse, repeat. Works for me.